CARC & RARC Denial Codes, Explained with Fixes

Every code below includes what it actually means, why it happens, and what to do about it, not just the official description. Type a code or keyword to filter instantly.

X12Maintains the CARC & RARC Lists
4 groupsCO, OA, PI, PR: Define Who Pays
RARCSupplemental Remark Codes Add Specific Detail
ERA / EOBWhere Denial Codes Appear on Every Remittance

Understanding CARC and RARC Codes on Your EOB

Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (CARCs) and Remittance Advice Remark Codes (RARCs) are the standardized codes insurance payers use to explain every payment, adjustment, or denial on an Explanation of Benefits (EOB) or Electronic Remittance Advice (ERA). Both code sets are maintained by X12. In X12's words, CARCs "describe why a claim or service line was paid differently than it was billed" (X12 CARC list), and RARCs "provide additional explanation for an adjustment already described" by a CARC or "convey information about remittance processing" (X12 RARC list). Every CARC is paired with one of four group codes on X12's current list: CO (Contractual Obligation), OA (Other Adjustment), PI (Payor Initiated Reduction) and PR (Patient Responsibility) (X12 group codes). The same code number carries different financial responsibility depending on whether it is prefixed CO or PR.

CO-16 (missing claim information) and CO-4 (procedure/modifier mismatch) are among the most common remittance denials, and both are preventable with front-end claim scrubbing. Timely filing limits differ by payer and contract (see our verified limits by payer), and CO-29 (timely filing) denials are rarely overturned without proof of original submission.

The most important insight for billers: the same CARC number can mean completely different things depending on the group code. CARC 96 as CO-96 means the provider cannot bill the patient (non-covered, contractual write-off). CARC 96 as PR-96 means the patient can be billed for the non-covered service. Read the group code before the number.

RARC codes (Remittance Advice Remark Codes) are supplemental codes that provide additional specificity, especially alongside CO-16. Where a CARC tells you a claim was denied for lacking information, the accompanying RARC tells you which information is missing: the ordering provider NPI, the diagnosis code, the attachment. Always read RARC codes before taking action on a CO-16 denial.

Use this reference to look up any code, filter the table below by code number or keyword. Click any linked code for a full guide with fix steps, appeal language, and prevention systems. The most common codes in practice, CO-45, CO-16, CO-97, CO-50, PR-1, each have dedicated pages with detailed fix workflows.

How to use this reference

This table covers the 70+ most-billed CARC and RARC codes. Each row shows the group+code pair, plain-English meaning, root cause, and required action. Codes in blue are linked to full pages with fix workflows, appeal templates, and prevention systems. Use the search box to filter by code number (e.g., CO-97), keyword (e.g., auth), or group (e.g., PR). For the complete X12-maintained list, see the X12 CARC table.

First: The Group Codes

Every adjustment arrives as a group code + reason code pair (e.g., CO-45). The group code tells you who eats the money:

COContractual Obligation

Provider absorbs it. Cannot be billed to the patient. Your contract created this adjustment.

Also see: CO-15 (retired authorization code)

PRPatient Responsibility

Billable to the patient: deductibles, copays, coinsurance, non-covered services with notice.

Also see: PR-96 (non-covered, patient pays)

OAOther Adjustment

Neither provider contract nor patient responsibility, commonly COB-related situations.

PIPayor Initiated Reduction

A reduction the payer initiated that isn't a contractual obligation or patient responsibility. Read the paired CARC and RARC before writing it off.

CARC Reason Codes

CodeWhat It Means (Plain English)Why It HappensHow to Fix & Prevent
CO-4Procedure code and modifier don't match, or a required modifier is missing.Missing anatomical modifier, missing 26/TC split, or modifier invalid for the code.Fix: add/correct the modifier and resubmit. Prevent: scrubber rule flagging modifier-required codes before submission.
CO-6Procedure/revenue code conflicts with the patient's age.Age-specific code billed for wrong-age patient (e.g., pediatric code for adult).Fix: verify DOB and code; correct whichever is wrong. Prevent: demographic validation at charge entry.
CO-8Procedure conflicts with the provider's taxonomy/specialty.Provider type not eligible to bill this service per payer rules.Fix: confirm taxonomy on file with payer matches the service. Prevent: credentialing file audit; correct taxonomy at enrollment.
CO-11Diagnosis doesn't support the procedure billed.Dx-procedure mismatch; medical necessity edit failed.Fix: review documentation; correct coding if supported; appeal with records if payer policy is wrong. Prevent: LCD/NCD and payer policy checks for flagged codes.
CO-16Claim lacks information or has a submission error, the catch-all "something's missing" code.Missing NPI, invalid member ID, absent required attachment, always arrives with a RARC telling you what.Fix: read the paired RARC code, supply the missing element, resubmit (this is a rejection-fix, not an appeal). Prevent: front-end claim edits; CO-16s are largely preventable. Full CO-16 guide
CO-18Exact duplicate of a claim already processed.Auto-rebilling before adjudication finished, or true double entry.Fix: confirm the original's status first: if it paid, no action; if it denied, fix the original reason. Prevent: claim-status checks before rebilling; disable blind auto-rebill.
CO-22Another payer should be billed first (coordination of benefits).Patient has other primary coverage per payer's COB file.Fix: bill the primary, then resubmit with the primary EOB. If COB info is outdated, have the patient update it with the payer. Prevent: COB question at every eligibility check. Full CO-22 guide
CO-23Prior payer's adjudication impacts this payment.Secondary claim where primary payment/adjustments already consumed the allowable.Fix: usually informational on secondaries: verify the math against both contracts. Prevent: post primary EOBs accurately before secondary submission.
CO-27Coverage terminated before the date of service.Patient's policy ended; eligibility wasn't checked or changed after check.Fix: re-verify coverage; if truly termed, bill the patient or their new plan. Prevent: real-time eligibility at every visit: the classic front-desk leak.
CO-29Timely filing limit expired.Claim submitted after the contract's filing window.Fix: appeal only with proof of timely original submission (clearinghouse acceptance report). Otherwise it's a write-off, and cannot be billed to the patient. Prevent: filing-deadline work queues; see our state filing tables. Full CO-29 guide
CO-45Charge exceeds the contracted/fee schedule rate, the standard contractual write-off.Normal on every paid claim; the gap between billed and allowed.Fix: none needed when the allowed amount is right. Audit: compare allowed vs. your loaded fee schedule, CO-45 is where underpayments hide. Full CO-45 guide
CO-50Service deemed not medically necessary by the payer.Documentation doesn't meet the payer's coverage policy, or policy wasn't checked.Fix: appeal with clinical notes, letter of medical necessity, relevant LCD/NCD citations; request peer-to-peer if denied again. Prevent: check coverage policies before high-dollar services. Full CO-50 guide
CO-59Payment reduced because multiple procedures were performed in the same surgical session.Multiple surgery rules applied: under Medicare's standard multiple-surgery rule the highest-valued procedure is paid at 100% and each additional one at 50%; other payers set their own rules.Check: verify primary is ranked highest-value, confirm no Modifier 51 exempt codes were reduced, and confirm procedures were truly same-session. Appeal only if reduction was incorrectly applied. Full CO-59 guide
CO-96Charge denied as non-covered per the plan.Service excluded from the benefit package.Fix: verify the exclusion is real (plans err); if valid and patient signed notice, bill patient. Prevent: benefit verification beyond eligibility: coverage ≠ eligibility. Full CO-96 guide
CO-97Payment for this service is bundled into another service already paid.NCCI edit: the code pair isn't separately payable without a valid modifier.Fix: check NCCI: if distinct service, add 59/XS/XE/XP/XU and resubmit with documentation. If bundling is correct, write off. Prevent: NCCI-aware scrubbing. Full CO-97 guide
CO-109Wrong payer: claim belongs to a different contractor/plan.Sent to the wrong Medicare contractor, wrong plan within a family, or carved-out benefit (e.g., behavioral health).Fix: identify the correct payer from the eligibility response and redirect. Watch your filing clock. Prevent: capture plan and carve-out details at verification. Full CO-109 guide
CO-110Billing date precedes the date of service.Data entry error in DOS or submission date.Fix: correct the date field and resubmit. Prevent: date-logic claim edits.
CO-119Benefit maximum reached for this period.Visit/unit/dollar cap exhausted (very common in therapy and chiropractic).Fix: verify the payer's count vs. yours; if exhausted, bill patient with notice. Prevent: track benefit caps in the PM system; warn patients as limits approach. Full CO-119 guide
CO-140Patient name and health ID number do not match payer records.Demographic mismatch: member ID or name on the claim differs from what the payer has on file.Fix: pull the insurance card, call payer to confirm exact name and ID on file, correct the claim data, and resubmit. Prevent: scan card and run eligibility at every visit. Full CO-140 guide
CO-151Units/frequency exceed what the payer allows for this service.MUE (medically unlikely edit) or frequency limit hit.Fix: verify units billed; if clinically justified, appeal with documentation and appropriate modifier. Prevent: MUE tables in the scrubber. Full CO-151 guide
CO-167Diagnosis not covered by this payer.Dx excluded under plan policy.Fix: review for more specific/accurate coding supported by documentation; appeal if policy misapplied. Prevent: payer dx-coverage lists for your top procedures. Full CO-167 guide
CO-170Payment is denied when performed or billed by this type of provider.The payer does not pay this service for the provider type or specialty on the claim; often a taxonomy or enrollment-specialty mismatch.Fix: read the remark code; compare taxonomy and specialty on the claim, in NPPES and in the payer enrollment; correct and resubmit, or update enrollment. Prevent: record which services each payer allows each provider type to bill. Full CO-170 guide
CO-177Patient has not met the required eligibility requirements.The patient was not eligible on the date of service, or does not qualify for the program or benefit billed.Fix: verify eligibility for the exact date of service; correct data and resubmit, or bill the correct payer; use retro-eligibility rules if coverage was approved later. Prevent: verify eligibility before every visit and save the response. Full CO-177 guide
CO-180Patient has not met the required residency requirements.Usually a program tied to where the patient lives, such as a state Medicaid program; the patient may have moved.Fix: confirm the address on the date of service and which program was responsible; correct address errors or bill the correct payer. Prevent: ask about recent moves at every registration. Full CO-180 guide
CO-181Procedure code was invalid on the date of service.The code was deleted, not yet effective, or does not exist for that date.Fix: find the code valid on the date of service that matches the documentation; resubmit as a corrected claim. Prevent: load annual CPT and quarterly HCPCS updates on time; scrub codes against the date of service. Full CO-181 guide
CO-182Procedure modifier was invalid on the date of service.The modifier was discontinued, not yet effective, or not accepted by the payer for that date. (A modifier that conflicts with the procedure is CO-4.)Fix: check the modifier's effective dates and the payer's modifier policy; resubmit with a valid modifier. Prevent: update modifier tables with each code release. Full CO-182 guide
CO-183The referring provider is not eligible to refer the service billed.Referring provider not enrolled in PECOS (Medicare), not a participating provider in the HMO's network, wrong NPI entered in Box 17, or not the patient's designated PCP in a gated plan.Fix: verify referring NPI in NPPES; check PECOS enrollment (pecos.cms.hhs.gov) for Medicare; for HMO plans confirm the referral came from the patient's designated PCP; correct NPI or obtain valid referral and resubmit. Prevent: referring provider PECOS/network verification before every specialist appointment. Full CO-183 guide
CO-184The prescribing/ordering provider is not eligible to order or prescribe the service billed.Most common on DME and home health claims: the ordering physician is not enrolled in PECOS as an ordering/referring provider. Also fires for wrong NPI in the ordering provider field, lapsed enrollment, OIG exclusion, or scope-of-practice restriction.Fix: verify ordering provider NPI in NPPES; check PECOS at pecos.cms.hhs.gov; also check OIG exclusion list; correct NPI or obtain new order from PECOS-enrolled physician. DME suppliers: verify PECOS enrollment before dispensing: CO-184 on a dispensed item means the supplier absorbs the cost. Full CO-184 guide
CO-185The rendering provider is not eligible to perform the service billed.Usually enrollment or credentialing: not enrolled, not linked to the group or location, or not active on the date of service.Fix: confirm the rendering NPI and enrollment dates (PECOS for Medicare); fix the record; resubmit or appeal. Prevent: confirm enrollment is effective before scheduling a new provider's patients. Full CO-185 guide
CO-197No prior authorization on file for a service that required it.Auth never obtained, expired, or doesn't match the service/units/provider billed.Fix: if auth existed, appeal with the auth number and approval letter. Retro-auth is possible with some payers within tight windows. Prevent: auth tracking tied to scheduling: one of the most preventable denials. See the PA guide. Full CO-197 guide
CO-198Authorization exists but its limits were exceeded.More units/visits delivered than approved.Fix: request additional units before continuing care; appeal overage with clinical justification. Prevent: real-time auth-unit tracking against scheduled visits.
CO-204Service not covered under the current benefit plan (CO variant).Plan exclusion where contract puts it on the provider.Fix: verify exclusion; check whether a covered alternative code accurately describes the service. Prevent: benefit checks for non-routine services.
CO-226Information requested from the billing provider wasn't received in time.Records request ignored or missed.Fix: submit the requested documentation and reopen. Prevent: a work queue for payer correspondence with owner and deadline.
CO-236Procedure combination not compatible per coding rules on the same day.NCCI procedure-to-procedure conflict across the claim.Fix: review the pair; modifier if truly distinct, else write off the column-2 code. Prevent: same-day compatibility edits pre-submission.
CO-252An attachment/documentation is required before adjudication.Payer needs notes, invoice, or certificate to process.Fix: send exactly what the paired RARC specifies via the payer's attachment channel. Prevent: attach known-required documents at first submission (common in DME). Full CO-252 guide
PR-1Deductible amount: patient owes it.Annual deductible not yet met.Fix: bill the patient. Prevent (surprises): collect estimated deductible at time of service based on eligibility response. Full PR-1 guide
PR-2Coinsurance amount: patient owes it.Patient's percentage share per plan.Fix: bill promptly: patient balances get harder to collect the longer they age. See patient collections guide. Full PR-2 guide
PR-3Copayment amount: patient owes it.Fixed visit copay.Fix/Prevent: collect at check-in, full stop. A copay uncollected at the desk costs more to chase than it's worth. Full PR-3 guide
PR-204Service not covered by the patient's current plan, patient responsible.Benefit exclusion; patient had no coverage for this service.Fix: bill patient if proper notice was given (ABN for Medicare). Prevent: benefit verification + signed financial notice before non-covered services. Full PR-204 guide
OA-18Duplicate claim (other-adjustment variant).Same as CO-18 where responsibility is unassigned.Fix: trace the original claim's outcome before any resubmission.
OA-23Prior payer adjudication impact (other-adjustment variant).Secondary-claim math after primary processing.Fix: verify secondary allowed amounts against contract; usually informational.

RARC Remark Codes

Remark codes ride along with reason codes (especially CO-16) to tell you the specific missing or problematic element:

CodeWhat It MeansWhat To Do
M15Separately billed services should have been bundled.Review NCCI; rebill bundled or modifier if distinct.
M20Missing/invalid HCPCS code.Verify the code is active for the DOS; check annual HCPCS updates.
M51Missing/invalid procedure code(s).Confirm code validity and format; watch deleted codes after Jan 1 / Jul 1 updates.
M76Missing/incomplete/invalid diagnosis.Check dx specificity (no truncated ICD-10) and pointer linkage.
M79Missing/invalid charge amount.Correct the charge field; often a claim-format issue from the PM system.
M81Diagnosis must be coded to the highest specificity.Replace 3-character category codes with full-specificity ICD-10 codes.
M127Missing patient medical record documentation.Submit records through the payer's documentation channel; calendar the deadline.
N29Missing documentation/orders/notes supporting the service.Attach the specific document type the payer's policy requires (orders, medical records, proof of delivery).
N30Patient ineligible for this service.Re-run eligibility; confirm benefit category and program (esp. Medicaid programs).
N56Wrong procedure code for the service documented.Recode from documentation, not from habit; verify with coding references.
N130Consult plan benefit documents for coverage rules.Pull the plan's coverage policy; determines whether appeal has any basis.
N179Additional information requested from the member.Claim stalls on the patient: notify them; COB questionnaires are the usual culprit.
N265Missing/invalid ordering provider identifier.Add the ordering provider's NPI; verify PECOS enrollment for Medicare orders.
N286Missing/invalid referring provider identifier.Correct referring NPI; required for many specialist and diagnostic claims.
N290Missing/invalid rendering provider identifier.Rendering NPI absent or doesn't match credentialed file, check enrollment records.
N362Units billed exceed allowed frequency.Verify units against MUE limits; appeal with documentation if clinically justified.
N381See contractual agreement for payment terms.Pull your contract: this is the payer saying the rate/rule is contractual; audit the math.
N522Duplicate of a claim already in process.Stop rebilling; check status of the in-process claim and work that one.

About This Reference

Descriptions are written in plain English by Ajay Pillai (CEO, Aayur Solutions) and the ABA team, not reproduced from official code sets. CARC and RARC codes are maintained by X12; consult the payer's remittance advice and the official X12 lists for authoritative definitions. Fix guidance reflects common payer behavior and our sourcing methodology: individual payer policies control. Updated October 2026.

Frequently Asked Questions

Claim reason codes: formally called Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (CARC), are standardized numeric codes assigned by insurance payers on the Explanation of Benefits (EOB) or Electronic Remittance Advice (ERA) to explain why a claim was adjusted, reduced, or denied. They always appear paired with a group code (CO, PR, OA or PI) that tells you who is financially responsible for the adjustment. CARC codes are maintained by X12, the body that governs electronic healthcare transactions under HIPAA.
CARC (Claim Adjustment Reason Code) is the primary explanation of why a claim was adjusted, for example, CO-97 means the service is bundled into another payment. RARC (Remittance Advice Remark Code) is a supplemental code that provides more specific detail, especially alongside CO-16. For example, CO-16 with RARC N265 tells you specifically that the missing element is the ordering provider's NPI. RARCs clarify; CARCs determine responsibility.
Group codes define who bears the financial responsibility for the adjustment. CO (Contractual Obligation) means the provider absorbs the adjustment and cannot bill the patient, contractually obligated write-off. PR (Patient Responsibility) means the balance can be billed to the patient, deductibles, copays, coinsurance, and non-covered services where the patient had notice. OA (Other Adjustment) applies when neither CO nor PR is appropriate, commonly used in COB situations. PI (Payor Initiated Reduction) marks a reduction the payer initiated that is not a contractual obligation or patient responsibility. The same CARC number has entirely different billing implications depending on the group code in front of it.
On a paper EOB or ERA, denial codes appear in the adjustment section for each claim line: first the group code (CO, PR, OA or PI), then the reason code number (e.g., 97), forming the pair CO-97. There may be a second code, the RARC, immediately after, which provides more specific detail. The dollar amount next to the code shows how much was adjusted for that reason. If you receive CO-16, always look for the paired RARC, it tells you exactly what information is missing.
The most frequent CARC codes across most practices are CO-45 (fee schedule write-off, appears on nearly every paid claim), CO-16 (missing information, the most common rejection trigger), CO-97 (bundled service), CO-50 (medical necessity), CO-29 (timely filing), CO-22 (COB, wrong payer order), CO-197 (no authorization), PR-1 (patient deductible), PR-2 (coinsurance), and PR-3 (copay). CO-45 is by volume the most frequent, but it's an expected adjustment; CO-97 and CO-50 represent actual claim losses that require action.
No: some adjustments are contractual and not appealable. CO-45 at the correct contracted rate is an expected write-off. CO-29 (timely filing) is only overturnable with proof the claim was submitted on time. PR-1, PR-2, and PR-3 are patient financial responsibilities, not appealable. The codes worth pursuing with appeals are: CO-50 (medical necessity, appeal with clinical documentation), CO-97 (bundling, appeal with modifier if services are clinically distinct), CO-170/CO-197 (auth-related, pursue retro-auth or emergency exception), and CO-16 (fix the error and resubmit, not an appeal).
CO-45 means the charge exceeds the fee schedule or contracted rate. It is not a true denial, it is the contractual write-off between your billed charge and the allowed amount. CO-45 only signals a problem when the allowed amount is lower than your contract says it should be, which is how underpayments hide in plain sight.
CO-97 means the benefit for this service is included in the payment for another service already adjudicated, a bundling denial. Check NCCI edits: if a modifier (such as 59 or an X modifier) legitimately applies, correct and resubmit; if the bundling is correct, the charge is a write-off.
PR-1 is the deductible: the amount the patient must pay out-of-pocket before insurance begins covering services. It is a patient responsibility code (PR group), meaning the provider can and should bill the patient for this amount. PR-1 appears on virtually every claim for a patient who hasn't met their annual deductible. Best practice is to collect estimated deductible at the time of service based on the eligibility verification response.
PR-204 means the service is not covered under the patient's current benefit plan. Because it is a PR code, the balance may be billed to the patient, but only if proper notice was given before service (ABN for Medicare, financial notice for commercial). Best practice is to verify benefits before non-routine services and have the patient sign a financial responsibility notice, so PR-204 never arrives as a surprise billing issue.
CO-16 is the catch-all 'claim lacks information or has a submission error' code. It always arrives with a paired RARC specifying the exact missing element, read the RARC first. Common RARC pairings: N265 (missing ordering provider NPI), N286 (missing referring NPI), N290 (missing rendering NPI), M76 (missing/invalid diagnosis). CO-16 is a rejection, not a denial, fix the identified element and resubmit. It is not appealed; it is corrected. CO-16 is one of the most preventable denials with front-end claim scrubbing.

Denials Keep Coming Back?

Codes tell you what happened. The denial management guide shows you how to make them stop.