Data Sources & Methodology
Updated November 2026
Every benchmark, denial statistic, and cost figure published on this site should be traceable. This page documents where our numbers come from, how we decide what to publish, and how we correct errors.
Our Sourcing Standard
Statistics on this site come from three tiers of evidence, always used in this order of preference:
1. Published Industry Data
Peer-reviewed studies, government datasets (CMS, KFF), and published surveys from recognized industry bodies, MGMA, HFMA, CAQH, Experian Health, Premier Inc., Kodiak Solutions, and the AMA.
2. Payer Documentation
Payer provider manuals, fee schedules, timely-filing policies, and prior-authorization requirements, taken directly from payer publications, not second-hand summaries.
3. Operational Experience
Patterns observed across 17+ years of real billing operations. When a figure comes from operational experience rather than published data, we present it as a range and say so.
Key Statistics Used on This Site
These are the figures that appear most often in our guides and benchmarks, with their sources:
| Statistic | Figure We Use | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Average initial claim denial rate | ~11.8% (range 10 to 12%) | Kodiak Solutions revenue cycle benchmarking; Experian Health State of Claims surveys; Change Healthcare Denials Index |
| Cost to rework a denied claim | $25.20 (average rework) to $118 (average appeal) | MGMA ($25.20 average rework, citing the Change Healthcare 2020 index; $118 average appeal cost); Premier Inc. ($43.84 per claim in 2022, $57.23 in 2023) |
| Share of denials that are preventable | 84% potentially avoidable | Optum 2024 Revenue Cycle Denials Index (2023 data) |
| Annual industry cost of claim denials | $25.7B spent adjudicating denials in 2023, up from $19.7B in 2022 | Premier Inc. (provider claims-adjudication costs, 2022 to 2023). |
| Clean claim rate target | 95%+ (top performers 96 to 99%) | HFMA MAP Keys; MGMA performance benchmarks |
| Days in AR benchmarks | <35 days best practice; 30 to 40 typical; specialty-specific ranges in our benchmark report | MGMA DataDive; HFMA MAP Keys; specialty society benchmarking |
| First-pass resolution rate target | 88 to 93% | HFMA MAP Keys; industry RCM benchmarking |
| Prior authorization as top denial driver | 13% of all denials (Optum 2024) | AMA prior-authorization physician surveys; Experian Health State of Claims; payer remittance (CARC) analyses |
| Marketplace / commercial denial variation | In-network denial rates vary widely by payer (some near 20%) | KFF Transparency in Coverage analyses of ACA marketplace plans |
| Timely filing limits by payer | Medicare 1 calendar year; commercial limits set by each payer and contract (see the timely filing limits page) | CMS claims processing manual; individual payer provider manuals (verified against payer publications at time of writing) |
How Content Gets Published
Every guide follows the same process before it goes live:
- Drafted from operations: content starts from real billing workflows, not keyword lists.
- Checked against published data: every statistic is verified against the sources listed above. If we can't source a number, we present it as an operational observation and label it as one.
- Dated: every guide carries an "Updated" date. Benchmarks are reviewed when major industry surveys are released (typically annually) and after significant payer policy changes.
- Free of commercial contingency: no guide, benchmark, or recommendation is contingent on any commercial relationship. See our operating disclosure.
What Our Numbers Can and Cannot Tell You
Benchmarks are directional, not diagnostic. A "good" denial rate varies by specialty, payer mix, and state, a DME supplier and a primary care office should not hold themselves to the same number. Where possible we publish specialty-specific ranges rather than single figures. Your own remittance data is always a better guide than any industry average.
Payer policies change constantly. Timely-filing windows, prior-authorization lists, and credentialing timelines cited in our guides were accurate when written and dated, but you should always verify against the payer's current provider manual before acting.
Corrections Policy
If you find a figure on this site that is outdated, unsourced, or wrong, email hello@americanbillingassociation.com with the page URL. Verified corrections are made promptly and the page's "Updated" date is revised. We would rather fix a number than defend it.
See the Data in Action
The 2026 RCM Benchmark Report compiles these sources into specialty-by-specialty performance tables.