Medical Billing Costs in 2026: Pricing Models and How to Compare Them

What does outsourced medical billing cost? How the three pricing models work, what a fee should cover, how to compare quotes with your own in-house cost, and the rules that apply to every model.

By Ajay Pillai, CEO, Aayur Solutions | 17+ years of RCM experience
Summary

Medical billing companies usually charge in one of three ways: a percentage of collections, a flat monthly fee, or a fee per claim. Rates depend on specialty, volume and what the fee covers, and there is no reliable public benchmark for them, so the only useful comparison is between written quotes and your own all-in in-house cost. Compare performance as well as price, and read the contract terms.

The Three Pricing Models

ModelHow it worksWhat to watch
Percentage of collectionsA share of what is actually collected, not what is billed. The most common model.Confirm which collections count (patient payments, old AR, refunds). Payments must go to the practice's account. OIG notes percentage arrangements can raise upcoding risk.
Flat monthly feeA fixed fee per month or per provider.Predictable, but the fee doesn't change with results. Check for volume caps and minimums.
Per-claim feeA fee for each claim submitted.Check whether resubmissions and appeals are charged again, and whether follow-up and denials are included.

Some companies combine models, for example a percentage plus a monthly minimum, or a separate fee for projects such as old AR or credentialing.

What the Fee Should Cover

Two quotes with the same rate can cover very different work. List each of these as included, extra, or not offered:

  • Charge entry and coding, or coding review
  • Claim scrubbing, submission and resubmission
  • Payment posting from ERAs and paper EOBs
  • Denial management and appeals
  • AR follow-up by payer and age
  • Patient statements and patient calls
  • Eligibility checks and prior authorization
  • Credentialing and payer enrollment
  • Old AR from before the contract started
  • Monthly reporting: net collection rate, denial rate by reason, days in AR

Your In-House Cost, Calculated

Add a year of: billing staff pay, benefits and payroll taxes, practice management software and clearinghouse fees, the share of space and equipment, the time the office manager or physician spends on billing, and turnover costs. For a reference point on pay, BLS reports 2025 median pay of $51,140 for medical records specialists, the category that includes medical coders.

All-in cost per dollar collected = total annual billing cost ÷ annual collections. Use the same collections figure to convert each vendor quote, then compare. The in-house vs. outsourced guide has a line-by-line worksheet.

Illustrative, not client data

  1. A practice collects $960,000 a year. One biller costs $54,000 in pay plus $14,000 in benefits and taxes; software and clearinghouse fees are $7,000; the share of space is $4,000; and management time is worth $10,000. Total: $89,000, or 9.3 cents per dollar collected.
  2. Quote A: 6% of collections ($57,600), covering claims, denials, AR follow-up and statements. Credentialing is extra.
  3. Quote B: $4,500 a month ($54,000), covering claims and posting only. Denials and AR follow-up would stay in-house, at an estimated $20,000 a year, so the comparable figure is $74,000.
  4. On cost alone Quote A is lowest, but the practice asks both companies for 12 months of reports from similar clients and compares denial rates and days in AR before deciding.

The figures above are invented to show the method. They are not market rates.

Rules That Apply to Every Pricing Model

  • Payments go to your account. Medicare pays a billing agent in the provider's name only if the agent's pay is not related to the amount billed or collected (Claims Processing Manual, Ch. 1, §30.2.4). A company paid a percentage should work from your remittances, not receive the money.
  • You remain responsible. OIG says it is no defense for a physician if the billing service bills Medicare improperly.
  • Business associate agreement. Required under HIPAA; it must provide for returning or destroying your patients' information at the end of the contract, where feasible (45 CFR 164.504(e)).

Contract terms to check

  • Notice period, termination fees and auto-renewal
  • Who works open claims after the contract ends, and at what fee
  • Data return in a standard format, including 835 remittance files
  • Minimum monthly fees and what triggers extra charges

See how to switch billing companies if you are moving from one company to another.

Medical Billing Cost FAQ

It depends on the pricing model, your specialty, your volume and what the fee covers. Billing companies usually charge a percentage of collections, a flat monthly fee or a fee per claim. There is no reliable public benchmark for these rates, so get written quotes from several companies and compare what each one includes.
There is no published standard. Judge a percentage by what it covers (coding, denials and appeals, patient statements, credentialing, old AR), by the performance the company can show for practices like yours, and by how it compares with your own all-in in-house cost per dollar collected.
Sometimes. Add up a year of in-house billing costs (staff pay, benefits and taxes, software, clearinghouse, space, management time and turnover), divide by annual collections, and compare that with written quotes. Compare performance too: net collection rate, denial rate and days in AR.
It varies by contract. Check whether the fee covers claim preparation and submission, payment posting, denial management and appeals, AR follow-up, patient statements and calls, credentialing, prior authorization, old AR from before the contract, and monthly reporting. Get the full scope in writing before signing.
Yes. OIG says percentage-based billing arrangements are not illegal, though it is concerned they can increase the risk of upcoding. Under Medicare rules, a billing company paid a percentage should not receive Medicare payments into an account it controls; payments should go to the practice's own account.

Disclosure: this site is operated by Aayur Solutions, a medical billing company. Educational content, not legal advice.

Sources

Find Out Exactly What Your Billing Should Cost

A free audit gives you a benchmark on what you're currently spending on billing, in-house or outsourced, and whether you're getting the performance that justifies the cost.