Non-Covered Charges: Patient Is Responsible
PR-96 means the payer treats the charge as non-covered and assigns it to the patient. Whether you can actually collect depends on the payer: for Medicare, statutorily excluded services are the patient's responsibility without an ABN, but services denied as not reasonable and necessary need a valid ABN. Commercial rules come from your contract.
PR-96 means this service is not covered by the patient's plan and the patient owes the amount. The PR group code authorizes patient billing. But there's a critical condition: for Medicare, it depends on why the service isn't covered. Services Medicare never covers by law (statutory exclusions, billed with modifier GY) are the patient's responsibility, and an ABN isn't required. Services expected to be denied as not reasonable and necessary need a valid ABN signed before the service (modifier GA); without one (GZ), the provider is usually liable. For commercial plans, your contract and state law decide whether advance notice is required.
CO-96 (same CARC number, different group code) means the provider absorbs the write-off, patient billing is prohibited. PR-96 means patient billing is authorized. Before sending any patient statement for a CARC 96 adjustment, verify the group code on the EOB is PR, not CO. Billing the patient for a CO-96 denial is a balance billing violation.
Official X12 definition: CARC 96
"Non-covered charge(s). At least one Remark Code must be provided (may be comprised of either the NCPDP Reject Reason Code, or Remittance Advice Remark Code that is not an ALERT.) Usage: Refer to the 835 Healthcare Policy Identification Segment (loop 2110 Service Payment Information REF), if present."
Start: 01/01/1995 | Last Modified: 07/01/2017, Source: X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Codes. The group code (PR) is assigned by the payer and tells you who is responsible for the adjusted amount (X12 group codes).
When you can bill the patient, and when you can't
✓ You CAN bill the patient when:
• Medicare, statutory exclusion: the service is never covered by Medicare (for example routine physicals or hearing aids) and was billed with modifier GY. No ABN is required.
• Medicare, medical necessity: you issued a valid ABN (CMS-R-131) before the service, the patient signed it, and the claim carried modifier GA.
• Commercial: You gave the patient a written financial responsibility notice before service, they signed it, and the service was rendered after that acknowledgment.
• The EOB group code is PR (not CO) for the 96 adjustment.
✗ You CANNOT bill the patient when:
• Medicare: the service was expected to be denied as not reasonable and necessary and no valid ABN was issued before the service (modifier GZ).
• The EOB group code is CO-96 (not PR-96), provider write-off, patient billing prohibited.
• You failed to verify non-coverage before service and didn't disclose the risk to the patient.
• The service was an emergency, different rules apply for emergency non-coverage.
How to handle PR-96: from pre-service verification to patient billing
- Verify non-coverage before the service is renderedRun eligibility and check the specific service against the patient's benefit exclusions. If the eligibility response doesn't clearly show the exclusion, call the payer's provider services line and ask specifically whether CPT [X] is covered for this patient. Document the verification with the payer rep name, date, and outcome. Non-coverage confirmed before service = valid basis for patient notice.
- Issue the appropriate advance notice and obtain patient signatureMedicare: Issue the ABN (CMS-R-131). Give it to the patient with enough time to make a genuine decision, not as they're being wheeled into a procedure room. The patient chooses: Option 1 (receive service, may pay if denied) or Option 2 (decline service). Commercial: Give a written financial responsibility notice showing the service, why it may not be covered, estimated cost, and asking for signature. File the signed notice in the patient's record.
- Submit the claim with the ABN modifier if applicableFor Medicare ABN situations where you believe coverage is uncertain (not certain denial), use modifier GA (ABN on file, patient agrees to pay if Medicare denies) or GX (voluntary ABN, patient chose to receive a non-covered service). These modifiers signal to Medicare that the patient has been notified. Without the correct modifier, Medicare may process the claim differently than intended.
- Confirm PR-96 (not CO-96) on the EOB before billing the patientWhen the EOB arrives, verify the group code is PR. If it's CO, do not bill the patient regardless of your ABN. Some services are contractually non-billable even with patient agreement. If you believe the payer applied CO-96 incorrectly where PR-96 should apply, call the payer to dispute the group code assignment before adjusting in your billing system.
- Bill the patient the exact PR-96 amount with a clear non-coverage explanationSend the patient statement for the exact PR-96 dollar amount from the EOB. Include a plain-language explanation: "Insurance did not cover this service because [reason]. You agreed to be responsible for this amount before the service was provided." Attach a copy of the EOB. Patients who understand why they're billed pay faster and dispute less.
Worked example, illustrative, not client data
A routine physical for a Medicare patient
- A Medicare patient asks for a routine annual physical (a preventive medicine visit such as 99397). Routine physicals are excluded from Medicare by law, unlike the Annual Wellness Visit (G0438/G0439), which Medicare covers.
- Because the service is a statutory exclusion, the claim goes out with modifier GY. No ABN is required, though you can give one voluntarily so the patient knows the cost in advance.
- The ERA comes back with PR-96 plus a remark code (X12 requires one for CARC 96). The PR group means the amount is the patient's responsibility.
- You bill the patient. Contrast: if the visit had been a covered service you expected Medicare to deny as not reasonable and necessary, you would have needed a signed ABN and modifier GA before you could bill the patient.
Frequently Asked Questions: PR-96
Codes related to PR-96
Getting PR-96 without having issued an ABN? You're writing off collectable revenue.
Every non-covered service rendered without proper advance notice is a preventable write-off. A free RCM audit identifies which non-covered services in your charge mix need an ABN or financial notice workflow, and builds the pre-service verification process that shifts those balances to the patient before service begins.