Processed Based on Multiple or Concurrent Procedure Rules
CO-59 usually means a procedure was paid, but at a reduced amount, because it was performed with other procedures in the same session. For surgery under Medicare's standard rule, the highest-valued procedure is paid in full and the second through fifth at 50%. The question to ask is whether the payer applied the right rule.
CO-59 means the payer reduced payment because of multiple or concurrent procedure rules, such as multiple surgery, multiple diagnostic imaging, or concurrent anesthesia. The official X12 description is: "Processed based on multiple or concurrent procedure rules. (For example multiple surgery or diagnostic imaging, concurrent anesthesia.)" A reduction is often correct; check that the right rule and ranking were applied before you appeal.
Official X12 definition: CARC 59
"Processed based on multiple or concurrent procedure rules. (For example multiple surgery or diagnostic imaging, concurrent anesthesia.)"
Start: 01/01/1995 | Last Modified: 07/01/2017, Source: X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Codes. The group code (CO, contractual obligation) is assigned by the payer and tells you who is responsible for the adjusted amount.
How Medicare's multiple surgery rule works
For codes with a multiple surgery indicator of "2" on the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule, Medicare ranks the procedures by fee schedule amount and pays the lower of the billed amount or (Claims Processing Manual, Ch. 12, §40.6):
- 100% of the fee schedule amount for the highest-valued procedure;
- 50% for the second through fifth highest-valued procedures;
- "By report" for the sixth and later, after manual review, and never less than 50%.
Other payers often follow this model but set their own rules in contracts and payment policies, so check yours.
Other rules that also produce CO-59
The fee schedule's multiple procedure indicator ("Mult Proc" in the relative value file, "Mult Surg" in the Physician Fee Schedule look-up) tells you which rule applies to each code:
- 0: no reduction. If one of these codes was reduced, ask why.
- 1: bilateral rules (with modifier 50) are a separate calculation from multiple surgery.
- 2: standard multiple surgery reductions, as above.
- 3: endoscopy family rules. Related endoscopies in the same family are paid using the difference from the base endoscopy, not a flat 50%.
- 4: diagnostic imaging. The technical component of each additional imaging service in the same session is reduced by 50%; professional components are reduced separately.
- 5: therapy. "Always therapy" services take a reduction to the practice expense portion of payment (Noridian: allowed amount reductions).
- 6 and 7: diagnostic cardiovascular and ophthalmology services have their own reductions.
How to check a CO-59 adjustment
- Look up each code's indicator in the fee schedule for the date of service.
- Check the ranking: the highest-valued procedure should be the one paid at 100%. A wrong ranking lowers total payment.
- Check exempt codes: add-on codes and codes with indicator 0 should not be reduced.
- Check the contract: a commercial contract may set different percentages than Medicare.
- Separate sessions: procedures in genuinely separate sessions on the same day may not be subject to the reduction; the documentation must show it.
- Appeal only when one of these checks shows the payer applied the wrong rule, ranking or percentage.
Frequently Asked Questions: CO-59
Codes related to CO-59
Seeing CO-59 on more than a few claims?
A repeating denial usually points to one upstream cause, such as eligibility checks, enrollment records, or code tables. A free RCM audit finds it and shows you the fix.