Top 10 Claim Denial Reasons (And How to Fix Each One)

Denial Management
Quick Answer

The 10 most common claim denial reasons: eligibility failures, missing prior auth, duplicate claims, COB errors, non-covered services, coding mismatches, timely filing, demographic errors, medical necessity, and credentialing gaps: account for the large majority of denials. Most are preventable at the front end before the claim is ever submitted. Your top three denial categories by volume usually drive most of your denial spend.

Claim denials cost US healthcare providers an estimated $25.7 billion in 2023 just to adjudicate (Premier Inc.). For an individual practice, rework costs about $25.20 per claim, and appealing a denied claim about $118 (Change Healthcare 2020 index, via MGMA), plus the revenue risk if appeals aren't filed in time. The national average denial rate is 11.8% (Kodiak Solutions, 2024 data), but practices with disciplined front-end processes can get well below it.

The good news: 84% of denials are potentially avoidable (Optum 2024 Revenue Cycle Denials Index). This guide breaks down each of the top 10 denial reasons, explains exactly why they happen, and gives you the specific operational fix for each one.

Top 10 Denial Reasons: Benchmark Data Table

The table below shows each denial category's share of total denials (where Optum reports it) and whether it's preventable at the front end or requires back-end intervention.

Denial Reason Share of Denials (Optum 2024) Preventable? CARC Code (Common)
Eligibility / Coverage Inactive 24% (registration & eligibility, the top cause) Yes, front end CO-26, CO-27
Missing / Invalid Prior Auth 13% (authorization / precertification) Yes, front end CO-15, CO-197
Duplicate Claim Not reported separately Yes, workflow CO-18
Coordination of Benefits Part of the 24% registration & eligibility category Yes, front end CO-22
Non-Covered Service Not reported separately Mostly, front end CO-96, CO-204
Coding Errors (CPT/ICD-10) Part of 16% missing / invalid claim data Partial, scrubber CO-4, CO-11, CO-16
Timely Filing Exceeded Not reported separately Yes, workflow CO-29
Demographic / Patient ID Error Part of the 24% registration & eligibility category Yes, front end CO-16, CO-31
Lack of Medical Necessity Not reported separately Partial, clinical CO-50, CO-167
Credentialing / Not In-Network Not reported separately Yes, proactive CO-B7, CO-170

Source: Optum 2024 Revenue Cycle Denials Index (2023 data). Categories Optum does not break out separately are marked. CARC codes are the most common ones used for each denial type.

1. Eligibility / Coverage Not Active

What it is: The patient's insurance was inactive, lapsed, or different from what was recorded at the time of service.

Why it happens: Eligibility is verified at registration and never again, or verified once for a new patient and assumed to carry forward for follow-up visits.

Fix: Run real-time eligibility verification on every patient, every visit, the morning of the appointment. Most PM systems support automated batch checks the night before. Use them.

2. Missing or Invalid Prior Authorization

What it is: The procedure required prior authorization and either none was obtained, or the authorization number is wrong/expired.

Why it happens: Authorization is requested after scheduling rather than before confirming the appointment. Or the authorization is obtained but not linked correctly to the claim.

Fix: No confirmed appointment for an authorization-required procedure until the auth number is in the chart. Train front desk and scheduling staff on payer-specific auth requirements by CPT code.

3. Duplicate Claim

What it is: The same claim was submitted more than once for the same date of service, patient, and procedure.

Why it happens: Manual resubmission errors, clearinghouse resubmissions without correcting the original, or PM system configuration issues.

Fix: Review your claim submission workflow to prevent resubmission of claims that are already in "pending" status. Duplicate claim denials should be zero, they indicate a process error.

4. Coordination of Benefits (COB) Issues

What it is: The patient has multiple insurance policies and the primary vs. secondary payer order is wrong or unknown.

Why it happens: COB information is captured at registration but not verified or updated. Life changes, marriage, job changes, Medicare enrollment, change COB status.

Fix: Verify COB during eligibility checks, especially for Medicare + commercial patients. When COB is unclear, call the payer before submitting rather than guessing the order.

5. Non-Covered Service

What it is: The payer doesn't cover the procedure for this patient's plan, even if the procedure is medically appropriate.

Why it happens: Coverage is not verified at the procedure level, only at the patient level. A patient with active coverage can still have non-covered procedures.

Fix: Verify benefits at the procedure level for high-cost, specialty, or frequently denied services. Collect patient responsibility upfront when coverage is limited or uncertain.

6. Coding Errors (CPT / ICD-10 Mismatch)

What it is: The diagnosis code doesn't support the procedure billed, or the CPT code is wrong, unbundled incorrectly, or missing required modifiers.

Why it happens: Outdated code sets, insufficient provider documentation, coder error, or PM system issues mapping charges to codes.

Fix: Run regular coding audits, at minimum quarterly. Use a claim scrubber that validates CPT/ICD-10 linkage. Address documentation issues with providers directly; coding errors that come from chart documentation cannot be fixed at the biller level.

7. Timely Filing Exceeded

What it is: The claim was submitted after the payer's filing deadline from the date of service.

Why it happens: Claims sit in work queues, get lost in system transitions, or are held for documentation that takes too long to obtain. Timely filing denials are uniquely bad because they are almost never appealable.

Fix: Set a workflow rule: any claim not submitted within 15 days of service date triggers an alert. Know each payer's timely filing window and track submissions accordingly. Commercial limits vary from 90 days (Cigna in-network) to 365 days (CareFirst), and Medicare allows 12 months (see verified payer limits).

8. Patient Not the Insured / Wrong Policy Holder

What it is: The claim was submitted under the wrong member ID, or the patient's demographic information doesn't match payer records.

Why it happens: Errors at registration, incorrect DOB, name spelling, or policy number. These look minor but produce hard denials.

Fix: Verify member ID and demographics against the insurance card at every visit. A patient whose name is "Elizabeth" on the card should not be entered as "Beth."

9. Lack of Medical Necessity

What it is: The payer determines the procedure wasn't medically necessary based on the documentation submitted.

Why it happens: Insufficient clinical documentation, missing diagnosis codes that establish medical necessity, or procedures billed at a level not supported by the documented encounter complexity.

Fix: Work with providers to ensure documentation supports the level of service billed. For high-risk procedures, review medical necessity criteria before submission. These denials require clinical involvement to resolve, billing staff alone cannot fix them.

10. Credentialing / Provider Not in Network

What it is: The rendering provider is not credentialed with the payer, or is credentialed under a different NPI or effective date than what's on the claim.

Why it happens: New providers see patients before their credentialing is complete. Or a credentialing update (new NPI, address change, group reassignment) was not processed correctly.

Fix: Never schedule a new provider to see insured patients before their credentialing is confirmed active. Run a credentialing audit for all providers every 6 months. Track effective dates and re-credentialing timelines proactively.

How to Prioritize: The 90-Day Denial Analysis Method

Don't try to fix all 10 denial reasons at once. That approach produces no results. Instead, use this three-step method that works consistently across practices of any size:

  1. Pull 90 days of remittances, export every denied claim with its CARC/RARC codes from your practice management system or clearinghouse.
  2. Sort by dollar volume, not count, a denial reason that hits 50 claims at $40 each ($2,000) matters less than one hitting 10 claims at $800 each ($8,000). Prioritize by total revenue impact.
  3. Identify your top three categories, in virtually every practice, a few denial reason groups account for most of the denial spend. Fix those three before touching anything else.

Once you've identified your top three, map each to the responsible workflow step. Eligibility failures trace to the front desk. Auth denials trace to scheduling. Coding denials trace to either the provider's documentation or the biller's code selection. Each root cause has a different owner and a different fix.

What a Good Denial Rate Looks Like

The national average initial denial rate was 11.8% in 2024 (Kodiak Solutions). We couldn't find free, independently verified denial rates by specialty, so we don't publish a specialty table. ABA's suggested target is 5% or lower. That is our own guideline, not a published benchmark. Track your own rate by payer and by reason code every month.

When to Escalate vs. Write Off a Denied Claim

Not every denial is worth appealing. Use this decision framework before routing a denied claim to your appeals team:

  • Always appeal: Medical necessity denials with solid clinical documentation; prior auth denials where auth was obtained but linked incorrectly; credentialing denials where the provider was credentialed but not yet updated in payer system.
  • Appeal selectively: Coding denials where the code was clinically supported but not documented, requires provider addendum. Success depends on what the record supports.
  • Consider write-off: Timely filing denials beyond the appeal window; duplicate denials where the original was actually paid; COB denials where patient secondary coverage cannot be established.

Many denials are winnable: Premier's survey of hospitals found about 70% of denials were eventually overturned and paid in 2023. Practices without a systematic appeal process recover far less, and that gap is recoverable revenue.

Key Takeaway

Pull your last 90 days of denials and sort by reason code. Your top three categories will usually account for most of your denial volume. Fix those three first; they are where most of your avoidable denials will be.

How often insurers deny prior authorization: in 2025, large insurers denied 12% of standard requests in Medicare Advantage, 14% in Medicaid managed care and 18% in ACA Marketplace plans, and 67%, 47% and 43% of appealed denials were overturned (KFF). See the rates by insurer in our prior authorization denial rates tracker.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most common reason for claim denial?

Missing or expired prior authorization is a leading denial reason, accounting for about 13% of denials (Optum 2024 Revenue Cycle Denials Index). Eligibility failures (inactive coverage at time of service) account for about 24% (Optum 2024). Together, these two categories drive nearly half of all preventable denials and are both fully fixable at the front end before the claim is submitted.

Can denied claims be resubmitted?

Yes, most denied claims can be corrected and resubmitted within the payer's timely filing window, which for commercial payers is set by each payer and contract, and for Medicare is 12 months. The critical exception is timely filing denials: once the filing window has passed, the denial is generally not reversible on appeal and the revenue is lost. This is why a 15-day submission workflow is essential.

What is a good claim denial rate for a medical practice?

ABA's suggested target is 5% or lower. That is our own guideline, not a published benchmark. A rate that is rising, or well above the 11.8% national average, needs attention. The national average is 11.8% (Kodiak Solutions, 2024 data), and Optum found 84% of denials are potentially avoidable. Specialty matters: DME practices often see much higher denial rates than a well-run primary care practice.

How much does a denied claim cost to rework?

Administrative rework costs about $25.20 per claim, and appealing a denied claim about $118 (Change Healthcare 2020 index, via MGMA). Simple eligibility corrections cost less; medical necessity appeals requiring clinical documentation and physician sign-off cost more. As a rough illustration only (the $25.20 figure comes from hospital data, so your costs will differ): 200 denials a month at $25.20 each would be about $5,040 a month in administrative cost, on top of the revenue at risk.

What percentage of denied claims can be overturned on appeal?

Many denials are winnable: Premier's survey of hospitals found about 70% of denials were eventually overturned and paid in 2023. Practices without a dedicated denial process recover far less, leaving appealable revenue on the table. The gap comes down to two things: appeal quality (clinical documentation vs. generic reconsideration letters) and speed (file well before the payer's appeal deadline).

Should I outsource denial management?

Consider outsourcing when: your denial rate is above 8% and hasn't improved after six months of internal effort; your team is filing follow-ups past the 30-day mark due to volume; or your AR over 90 days is growing. A specialist denial management partner brings payer-specific appeal templates, clinical documentation support, and the volume experience to identify payer behavior patterns your internal team may miss. For most practices, the ROI calculation is straightforward: if a partner recovers 3% additional net collections on a $2M revenue base, that's $60,000/year before subtracting the partner's fee.

Free denial reason analysis for your practice

Book a free RCM audit and we'll categorize your top denial reasons against 2026 benchmarks, and tell you exactly what to fix first.

Book Free RCM Audit
Sources
Ajay Pillai
Ajay Pillai CEO, Aayur Solutions

Ajay has 17+ years of hands-on revenue cycle management experience, having worked denial appeals with major commercial payers, built AR recovery programs for practices with Days in AR above 60, and managed DME prior authorization workflows across multiple specialties. He founded Aayur Solutions and built the American Billing Association as a free, operator-first RCM education resource.

LinkedIn About ABA

Know your top denial reasons. Then fix them.

Book a free RCM audit to identify your highest-impact denial categories and get a specific action plan.